Reevaluating Special Education Inclusion: Insights from the Latest Research

At Morgan Learning, we are committed to staying at the forefront of educational research and its implications for our practices. Recently, we had the opportunity to delve into a thought-provoking webinar discussing a new research review published by The Hechinger Report. This review critically examines the evidence supporting the inclusion of students with disabilities in general education classrooms. As an educator with 17 years of experience, including extensive work as a special educator, this topic resonates deeply with me and challenges us to rethink our approaches to special education.

Key Takeaways from the Research Review

The review, led by Nina Dalgaard and published by the Campbell Collaboration, analyzed over 2,000 studies on special education inclusion but found that only 15 of these studies met rigorous standards for comparison. The findings were surprising and somewhat disheartening: there is no clear evidence that students with disabilities benefit academically, psychologically, or socially from being included in general education classrooms compared to those in separate special education settings.

Key points from the review include:

• Inconsistent Benefits: While some students thrived in inclusive settings, others did not. The overall academic and psychosocial outcomes were not significantly better for students in inclusive classrooms.

• Variable Outcomes by Disability Type: The review hinted that students with autism, for example, might fare better in separate settings. However, more research is needed to confirm these observations.

• Importance of Co-Teaching Models: Schools that implemented co-teaching models—pairing a general education teacher with a special education teacher—saw better outcomes for students with disabilities in inclusive settings. Despite this, such models are often cost-prohibitive.

Implications for Practice

As educators, these findings prompt us to reflect critically on our current practices and policies regarding inclusion. Here are some implications and potential action steps:

1. Customized Approaches: Recognize that inclusion is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Each student's needs are unique, and their educational settings should reflect this. For some, separate specialized instruction may be more beneficial.

2. Invest in Co-Teaching: Advocate for and invest in co-teaching models where feasible. The collaboration between general and special education teachers can create more supportive and effective learning environments.

3. Focus on Training: Enhance professional development for all educators on how to effectively support students with disabilities, whether in inclusive or separate settings. Understanding diverse learning needs and adapting teaching strategies accordingly is crucial.

4. Evaluate Resources: Ensure that inclusion does not become a cost-cutting measure that deprives students of necessary resources. Adequate support and specialized services must be maintained, regardless of the setting.

5. Ongoing Research and Adaptation: Stay informed about the latest research and be willing to adapt practices based on new evidence. Education is an ever-evolving field, and what works best for students may change as we learn more.

A Call to Action

The discussion around inclusion is complex and multifaceted. As educators, we must advocate for policies and practices that truly serve the best interests of all students. Here are some steps we can take:

• Engage in Dialogue: Join conversations with policymakers, researchers, and fellow educators to share insights and experiences about what works in special education.

• Support Research: Advocate for more comprehensive and nuanced research into special education practices to better understand the needs and outcomes of diverse student populations.

• Empower Families: Work closely with families of students with disabilities to ensure their voices are heard and their children's needs are met in educational planning.

In conclusion, the findings from this research review challenge us to rethink and refine our approaches to special education. At Morgan Learning, we are committed to continuously improving our practices to provide the best possible education for all students. Let’s use this opportunity to critically assess our methods, embrace effective strategies, and advocate for the resources and support our students deserve.

Stay tuned for more insights and updates on educational research and best practices from Morgan Learning. Together, we can create a more inclusive and effective learning environment for every student.

---

Access all Morgan Learning stores, products, and resources with the link below.

https://linktr.ee/MorganLearning

---